IDFC FIRST Private vs ICICI Emeralde Private Metal
ICICI Emeralde Private Metal by ₹5,400 a year at ₹75,000 a month
Axis Bank
Below ₹2.5 lakh a month IDFC FIRST Private is the better card; from ₹2.5 lakh up, Axis Magnus for Burgundy takes over, and by ₹5 lakh a month it is ₹2,25,000 a year ahead. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: IDFC FIRST Private returns ₹51,000 a year in rewards to Axis Magnus for Burgundy's ₹36,300. Pick Axis Magnus for Burgundy instead if airport lounges matter more to you than the money: it gets you into 679 of the lounges we track to IDFC FIRST Private's 83, or if you want to move points to airlines and hotels: its points reach 27 transfer partners to IDFC FIRST Private's none. IDFC FIRST Private is by invitation only; Axis Magnus for Burgundy is the one you can apply for directly.
IDFC FIRST Private charges twice — ₹50,000 to join, then ₹25,000 every year after.
| Fact | Axis Magnus for Burgundy | IDFC FIRST Private |
|---|---|---|
| Can you get it | Open to apply✓ Better | By invitation only |
| Fee (joining · annual, + GST) | ₹30,000/yr✓ Better | ₹50,000 joining, then ₹25,000/yr |
| Fee waiver | Spend ₹30,00,000 a year | None |
| Reward rate on everyday spend | 4.8% | 6.7%✓ Better |
| Points | Axis EDGE Reward Points | IDFC FIRST Reward Points |
| Our value per point | ₹0.40 | ₹0.25 † |
| Transfer partners | 27✓ Better | None |
| Lounges it gets you into | 679 of 810✓ Better | 83 of 810 |
| Forex markup | 2% + GST | Nil✓ Better |
| Welcome benefit | ₹5,000 voucher — Luxe gift card, The Postcard Hotels or Yatra (new cards only; customers upgraded from plain Magnus get nothing) | 50,000 reward points on paying the ₹50,000 commencement fee — worth ₹50,000 at the app-travel rate. Cards issued on or after 17 Jul 2026 no longer get the Club ITC Culinaire membership; it was discontinued that day |
✓ Better marks the side that wins a row; rows that compare unlike things are not scored. They split the 12 rows we can call 6–6.
| Fact | Axis Magnus for Burgundy | IDFC FIRST Private |
|---|---|---|
| Our rank | #1 | Not ranked (invite-only) |
| Our verdict | Keep | Keep |
| Lounge visits in India | Unlimited at the 20 rooms on Axis's Set B list — present the card itself. Since 28-08-2026 the Priority Pass card is not valid at an Indian domestic lounge, so there is no free Priority Pass entry there and no paid one either; PP still works abroad and at the post-immigration lounges Axis counts as international | Unlimited — IDFC publishes no room list for Private, so the doors are not enumerated here |
| Lounge visits abroad | Unlimited (Priority Pass) | Unlimited |
| Forex, in the bank’s words | 2% + GST. Dynamic currency conversion markup 2% since 28 August 2026, up from 1.5% — NOT the bank-wide 3.5% — per Magnus's own revision notice | Nil — 0% markup on foreign currency and DCC transactions |
| Interest (APR) | 3.0%/mo (42.58%/yr, compounded as quoted by Axis) | 0.75%/mo (9%/yr) — the lowest retail APR in the catalog (official Private page) |
| Income needed (salaried) | Burgundy relationship required — official criteria: net salary credit above ₹3L/month in an Axis Salary Account, or ₹10L AMB in savings, or ₹30L TRV (₹1Cr incl. demat) | not published |
| Income needed (self-employed) | Same Burgundy gates via balances: ₹10L AMB in savings or ₹30L TRV (₹1Cr incl. demat), consistently maintained through the month | not published |
Where their lounge doors differ (Axis Magnus for Burgundy against IDFC FIRST Private): New York (JFK) 10 against 0 · Tokyo (NRT) 9 against 0 · Dubai (DXB) 12 against 4.
† IDFC FIRST Private: Private redeems the IDFC point at ₹1.00 on the FIRST Travel & Shop portal — FOUR TIMES the ₹0.25 house value, the top tier on IDFC's ladder alongside Gaj — and ₹0.25 everywhere else. The earn rate is scaled UP to that ₹1.00 portal reality; it collapses to a quarter of the headline the moment you cash out, points cover at most 70% of a booking, and app-travel redemptions are capped at 600,000 points a calendar year.
Our value per point is what we think a point is worth when you use it well; every currency's figure and its reasoning is on points values.
| Monthly spend | Axis Magnus for Burgundy | IDFC FIRST Private |
|---|---|---|
| At ₹30,000 a month | −₹15,500 | −₹4,600✓ Better |
| At ₹75,000 a month | ₹6,300 | ₹26,000✓ Better |
| At ₹1.5 lakh a month | ₹42,600 | ₹77,000✓ Better |
| At ₹3 lakh a month | ₹2,57,800✓ Better | ₹1,79,000 |
| At ₹5 lakh a month | ₹5,40,000✓ Better | ₹3,15,000 |
| Pays for itself from | ₹63,000 a month | ₹37,000 a month✓ Better |
On an everyday mix of spending (groceries, bills, travel, fuel and the rest), using each card's own rules for each kind of spend. The same figures as each card's own page.
| Monthly spend | Axis Magnus for Burgundy | IDFC FIRST Private | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹25,000 | −₹17,900 | −₹8,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹9,900 |
| ₹30,000 | −₹15,500 | −₹4,600✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹10,900 |
| ₹50,000 | −₹5,800 | ₹9,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹14,800 |
| ₹75,000 | ₹6,300 | ₹26,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹19,700 |
| ₹1 lakh | ₹18,400 | ₹43,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹24,600 |
| ₹1.25 lakh | ₹30,500 | ₹60,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹29,500 |
| ₹1.5 lakh | ₹42,600 | ₹77,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹34,400 |
| ₹1.75 lakh | ₹54,700 | ₹94,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹39,300 |
| ₹2 lakh | ₹86,600 | ₹1,11,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹24,400 |
| ₹2.25 lakh | ₹1,21,900 | ₹1,28,000✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Private by ₹6,100 |
| ₹2.5 lakh | ₹1,57,200✓ Better | ₹1,45,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹12,200 |
| ₹2.75 lakh | ₹1,92,500✓ Better | ₹1,62,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹30,500 |
| ₹3 lakh | ₹2,57,800✓ Better | ₹1,79,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹78,800 |
| ₹3.25 lakh | ₹2,93,000✓ Better | ₹1,96,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹97,000 |
| ₹3.5 lakh | ₹3,28,300✓ Better | ₹2,13,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹1,15,300 |
| ₹3.75 lakh | ₹3,63,600✓ Better | ₹2,30,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹1,33,600 |
| ₹4 lakh | ₹3,98,900✓ Better | ₹2,47,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹1,51,900 |
| ₹4.25 lakh | ₹4,34,200✓ Better | ₹2,64,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹1,70,200 |
| ₹4.5 lakh | ₹4,69,400✓ Better | ₹2,81,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹1,88,400 |
| ₹4.75 lakh | ₹5,04,700✓ Better | ₹2,98,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹2,06,700 |
| ₹5 lakh | ₹5,40,000✓ Better | ₹3,15,000 | Axis Magnus for Burgundy by ₹2,25,000 |
We put each card through the same everyday mix of spending, apply that card's own rules for each kind of spend (some earn nothing on fuel or bills), add its milestone and renewal bonuses at our value per point, and take off the fee unless that spend waives it. Bonus categories that need you to shop a certain way are not counted. Your own mix will differ: try your numbers in the calculator, or read how we value cards.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy's Axis EDGE Reward Points move to 27 airline and hotel partners; IDFC FIRST Private's IDFC FIRST Reward Points cannot be moved to any.
Only Axis Magnus for Burgundy: Singapore Airlines KrisFlyer, Finnair Plus (Avios), Qatar Airways Privilege Club (Avios).
Every partner and ratio is on each card's page; the best value for your points is on the transfer optimizer.
Below ₹2.5 lakh a month IDFC FIRST Private is the better card; from ₹2.5 lakh up, Axis Magnus for Burgundy takes over, and by ₹5 lakh a month it is ₹2,25,000 a year ahead. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: IDFC FIRST Private returns ₹51,000 a year in rewards to Axis Magnus for Burgundy's ₹36,300. Pick Axis Magnus for Burgundy instead if airport lounges matter more to you than the money: it gets you into 679 of the lounges we track to IDFC FIRST Private's 83, or if you want to move points to airlines and hotels: its points reach 27 transfer partners to IDFC FIRST Private's none. IDFC FIRST Private is by invitation only; Axis Magnus for Burgundy is the one you can apply for directly.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy beats IDFC FIRST Private by ₹78,800 a year at ₹3 lakh a month. Both figures are a year's rewards and bonuses on an everyday spending mix, after the fee.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy: ₹30,000/yr against ₹50,000 joining, then ₹25,000/yr. Axis Magnus for Burgundy waives its fee if you spend ₹30,00,000 a year; IDFC FIRST Private has no fee waiver.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy: 679 of the 810 lounges we track, against 83 for IDFC FIRST Private. Visit limits and guest charges differ by card; each card's page lists them.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, IDFC FIRST Private on 24 Oct 2026. Every figure here is worked out again from those records each time the site is built, so a change to either card shows up the day we log it.
Axis Magnus for Burgundy was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, IDFC FIRST Private on 24 Oct 2026. Every fact above comes from these 19 documents; the banks' own are marked official. A fact a bank does not publish shows as "not published", never as zero.