Head to head

Card vs card, with real math.

Every comparison below runs both cards through the same engine — net annual value at ₹1L, ₹3L and ₹5L a month, lounge doors, transfer reach — and calls a winner. No fence-sitting, no 153-page pair spam: only the fights with genuine tension.

Super-premium title fights

Metal vs metal — the five-figure-fee cards that headline the rankings.

ICICI Emeralde Private Metal vs HDFC Infinia Metal

The quiet over-achiever vs the king — near-identical fees, and iShop redemptions skip the transfer gymnastics entirely.

#4 Keep #1 Keep Who wins →
Axis Bank Reserve vs Amex Platinum Charge

₹50,000 vs ₹66,000 for lounges, golf and status — neither is a rewards card, so which benefit stack earns its keep?

#17 Keep #21 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Infinia Metal vs Axis Magnus for Burgundy

#1 vs #2 — the most rounded card in the country against the hardest-earning one.

#1 Keep #3 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Infinia Metal vs Amex Platinum Charge

₹12,500 of everything vs ₹66,000 of everywhere-but-points — the value engine against the status machine.

#1 Keep #21 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Emeralde Private Metal vs HDFC Diners Club Black Metal

Two metal near-twins: ICICI's ₹1/point iShop portal vs Diners' quarterly 10,000-point bonus engine.

#4 Keep #5 Keep Who wins →
Axis Bank Reserve vs HDFC Infinia Metal

Invitation-only lounges-and-golf vs the most complete card in India — a ₹50,000 fee has to argue very hard.

#17 Keep #1 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Emeralde Private Metal vs Axis Magnus for Burgundy

₹12,499 of portal value vs ₹30,000 of 5:4 transfer firepower — two very different routes to super-premium value.

#4 Keep #3 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Times Black vs HDFC Infinia Metal

₹20,000 of helicopter transfers vs ₹12,500 of everything — the king nets ₹39,960 to Times Black's ₹4,000 at ₹1L a month.

#18 Keep #1 Keep Who wins →
HSBC Premier (Metal) vs HDFC Infinia Metal

3% behind a wealth gate vs 3.3% behind a waitlist — Infinia out-earns it at every spend level, but Premier's fee is nil if you qualify.

#8 Keep #1 Keep Who wins →
HSBC Premier (Metal) vs Axis Magnus for Burgundy

Two cards for the already-rich: 3% flat and effectively free vs 4.8% behind a ₹30,000 fee — Burgundy pulls ahead past ₹1L a month.

#8 Keep #3 Keep Who wins →
Amex Platinum Reserve vs Axis Bank Reserve

Two cards named Reserve, neither a rewards engine: ₹10,000 of Amex lounges and ₹12,000 vouchers vs ₹50,000 of invite-only golf and concierge — which benefit stack earns its fee?

#25 Keep #17 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Private vs ICICI Emeralde Private Metal

Two invite-only metal super-premiums, both closed loops behind a velvet rope — IDFC's ₹50,000 6.67% travel-portal engine vs ICICI's ₹12,499 ₹1 iShop.

#29 Keep #4 Keep Who wins →
Kotak White Reserve vs HDFC Diners Club Black Metal

₹12,500-ish metal, opposite religions: Kotak earns nothing per swipe and pays you in spend milestones and unlimited lounges; the Diners Black pays 3.3% on everything and transfers to airlines.

#42 Keep #5 Keep Who wins →
Kotak White Reserve vs Amex Platinum Charge

Two cards that beg you to ignore the points: White Reserve's ₹12,500 milestone-and-lounge machine vs the ₹66,000 Platinum's status stack — which benefits pile actually earns its fee?

#42 Keep #21 Keep Who wins →

Premium rivalries

The ₹2,500–₹6,000 tier, where most people actually pick a card.

HSBC TravelOne vs Axis Atlas

Twenty 1:1 partners at ₹4,999 vs the 1:2 KrisFlyer doubling — breadth against depth.

#14 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
HSBC TravelOne vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

Two sub-₹5,000 transfer hubs: HSBC's instant Avios moves vs the widest 1:1 airline list on any Indian bank card.

#14 Keep #37 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Mayura vs Standard Chartered Ultimate

Portal multipliers and milestones vs a flat 3.33% with a hard ceiling — upside against the best boring card in India.

#11 Keep #15 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Regalia Gold vs HSBC TravelOne

The freshly trimmed mid-premium stalwart vs the upstart transfer hub — ₹2,500 of habit against ₹4,999 of ambition.

#10 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
Axis Atlas vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

The 1:2 doubling against the widest 1:1 partner list — India's two dedicated miles cards, one winner per spend style.

#2 Keep #37 Keep Who wins →
Standard Chartered Ultimate vs HSBC TravelOne

A guaranteed ₹1 per point vs a transferable maybe — certainty against upside at the same ₹5,000.

#15 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Mayura vs HSBC TravelOne

App-portal multipliers up to 13.3% vs twenty 1:1 airline partners — two premium plays near ₹5–6k, zero overlap.

#11 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
Amex Platinum Travel vs Axis Atlas

Milestone vouchers vs transferable miles at the same ₹5,000 fee — the predictable spender against the frequent flyer.

#16 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Sapphiro vs HDFC Regalia Gold

Two downgrade verdicts fight for the sock drawer — voucher confetti vs a freshly trimmed stalwart.

#52 Downgrade #10 Keep Who wins →
Amex Membership Rewards Card vs HDFC Regalia Gold

The entry-level discipline test vs mid-premium autopilot — ₹4,500 of milestones against ₹2,500 of habit.

#22 Keep #10 Keep Who wins →
Axis Horizon vs HSBC TravelOne

Two starter transfer hubs: Horizon's halved 1:1 miles at ₹3,000 vs TravelOne's twenty 1:1 routes, which out-earn it from ₹75k a month.

#28 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
RBL World Safari vs IDFC FIRST Mayura

Both charge 0% at the border; only one pays you at home — Mayura's 1.7% laps Safari's 0.5% at every spend level we model.

#39 Keep #11 Keep Who wins →
Scapia (Federal Bank) vs RBL World Safari

The same 0%-forex trade, free vs ₹3,000 a year — Scapia's 2% coins beat Safari's 0.5% points and its fee, so Safari has to argue very hard.

#24 Keep #39 Keep Who wins →
Scapia (Federal Bank) vs IDFC FIRST Mayura

Zero forex for free vs zero forex for ₹5,999 — Mayura's portal multipliers and open-ended lounges against Scapia's coin lock-in and ₹20k monthly bar.

#24 Keep #11 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Tiger vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

Two 1:1 Maharaja pipes: SBI's ₹4,999 of instant 2/₹200 breadth vs Tiger's free slab engine that out-earns it once you cross ₹5L a year.

#12 Keep #37 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Tiger vs Scapia (Federal Bank)

India's two best lifetime-free travel cards want different lives — Tiger banks Maharaja miles at high spend, Scapia banks lounge visits and border crossings.

#12 Keep #24 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Ashva vs Axis Horizon

₹2,999 of closed-loop metal vs ₹3,000 of real 1:1 miles — Ashva nets more (₹28,789 vs ₹21,000 at ₹1L a month), Horizon's points actually leave the building.

#13 Keep #28 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Ashva vs HSBC TravelOne

Ashva's 10X tier out-earns TravelOne from ₹1.75L a month — but one currency transfers to twenty airlines and the other dies inside an app at ₹0.40.

#13 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
BOBCARD Etihad Guest Premium vs Axis Atlas

India's two hardest-earning miles cards: 5.8% into one airline vs 4% into twenty — the milestone stack wins the spreadsheet, Atlas wins the flexibility.

#7 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
BOBCARD Etihad Guest Premium vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

Direct 2 miles/₹100 into Etihad vs 1% into ~25 programs at 1:1 — BOBCARD nets ₹70,000 to MILES ELITE's ₹27,001 at ₹1L a month, if you'll actually fly Etihad.

#7 Keep #37 Keep Who wins →
BOBCARD Etihad Guest Premium vs RBL World Safari

Both waive the 3.5% border tax; only one pays you back — 2 miles/₹100 against Safari's 0.5% closed loop, at ₹2,000 more fee that ₹5L of spend erases.

#7 Keep #39 Keep Who wins →
AU Ananta vs RBL World Safari

Two small-bank travel cards nobody should take abroad on the same day — Ananta's 3.49% forex vs Safari's 0%, and neither earns 1% at home.

#43 Cancel #39 Keep Who wins →
AU Ananta vs Axis Horizon

₹2,000 of closed-loop catalogue points vs ₹3,000 of honest 1:1 miles — Horizon out-earns Ananta at every spend level and its points actually fly.

#43 Cancel #28 Keep Who wins →
Emirates Skywards ICICI Bank Emeralde vs BOBCARD Etihad Guest Premium

Gulf-carrier co-brands, opposite maths: Emirates Skywards at 2 miles/₹100 with no fee waiver vs Etihad Guest at 2/₹100, 0% forex and a milestone stack — BOBCARD out-earns it everywhere except the Emirates route itself.

#35 Keep #7 Keep Who wins →
Emirates Skywards ICICI Bank Sapphiro vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

One airline vs twenty-five: 1.5 Skywards Miles/₹100 locked to Emirates vs SBI's 2/₹200 into ~25 programs at 1:1 — breadth buries the single-program lock-in at the same ₹5,000.

#40 Downgrade #37 Keep Who wins →
MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank vs Scapia (Federal Bank)

Two cheap travel cards that die inside an app: MMT's 0.99% forex + 6% hotel myCash at ₹999 vs Scapia's 0% forex and coins for free — Scapia wins the border, MMT wins the booking.

#41 Keep #24 Keep Who wins →
SBI Card MILES PRIME vs HSBC TravelOne

Two sub-₹5,000 transfer hubs: SBI's widest-on-the-market 1:1 airline list at a 1% engine vs TravelOne's twenty 1:1 partners that out-earn it from ₹75k a month.

#30 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
BOBCARD Eterna vs YES Bank RESERV

Same ₹2,499 fee, same online-accelerated closed loop — but Eterna pays 3.75% as real statement credit while RESERV's 3% is trapped in a ₹0.25 portal whose only exit is a 15:1 decoy.

#31 Keep #36 Downgrade Who wins →
BOBCARD Eterna vs AU Ananta

Two small-bank cards, ₹0.25 points each — but Eterna's redeem as flat cashback at 3.75% with unlimited lounges, and Ananta's pay 0.5% behind a ₹99 exit fee. It isn't close.

#31 Keep #43 Cancel Who wins →
Axis Bank SELECT vs HDFC Regalia Gold

₹3,000 of Priority Pass international lounges vs ₹2,500 of transferable HDFC points — the lounge card against the mid-premium all-rounder, both redeeming below their sticker.

#33 Keep #10 Keep Who wins →
OneCard Metal vs Scapia (Federal Bank)

Two lifetime-free forex cards: OneCard's 1% markup with zero lounges vs Scapia's 0% markup, unlimited domestic lounges and 2% coins — the free card that does more wins easily.

#56 Keep #24 Keep Who wins →
OneCard Metal vs Federal Bank Celesta

Two lifetime-free cards that barely pay: OneCard's 1% forex and no lounge vs Celesta's 2% forex and two free international lounges — pick the perk you'll actually use.

#56 Keep #57 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Wealth vs IndusInd Tiger

Two lifetime-free 1.5%-forex cards — Wealth's never-expiring closed-loop points vs Tiger's slab-earned 1:1 Maharaja miles that actually reach an airline.

#48 Keep #12 Keep Who wins →
RBL Icon vs AU Zenith+

Two ~₹5,000 premium travel cards — Icon's capped 20X and 3.5% forex vs Zenith+'s 0.99% forex and 32 lounge visits; one earns, the other travels cheap.

#38 Downgrade #58 Cancel Who wins →
Kotak Privy League Signature vs IndusInd Tiger

Two cheap lounge cards, opposite bets: Kotak's relationship Priority Pass and ₹0.25 points vs Tiger's lifetime-free slab engine that banks real 1:1 Maharaja miles.

#47 Downgrade #12 Keep Who wins →

Family feuds

Same issuer, same ecosystem — which sibling deserves the spend?

HDFC Infinia Metal vs HDFC Diners Club Black Metal

Same engine, same points, same partners — the only real questions are Visa acceptance and a 10,000-point quarterly bribe.

#1 Keep #5 Keep Who wins →
Axis Atlas vs Axis Magnus for Burgundy

₹5,000 of focus vs ₹30,000 of firepower behind a velvet rope — Axis's two survivors fight over your travel spend.

#2 Keep #3 Keep Who wins →
Axis Magnus (legacy) vs Axis Atlas

The gutted legend vs the purpose-built miles machine — the answer flips at ₹1.5 lakh a month.

#6 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
Amex Platinum Travel vs Amex Membership Rewards Card

Amex's two MR on-ramps: annual milestone tiers at ₹5,000 vs monthly swipe discipline at ₹4,500.

#16 Keep #22 Keep Who wins →
Marriott Bonvoy HDFC Bank vs HDFC Regalia Gold

A free hotel night on autopilot vs a general-purpose card that just got trimmed — HDFC's two small-fee siblings.

#9 Keep #10 Keep Who wins →
Axis Magnus (legacy) vs Axis Magnus for Burgundy

Same card, two fates: the 5:2 casualty vs the 5:4 survivor — is the Burgundy gate worth double the transfer ratio?

#6 Keep #3 Keep Who wins →
Amex Gold Charge vs Amex Membership Rewards Card

Six swipes vs two milestones — Amex's habit cards go head-to-head for your monthly routine.

#46 Keep #22 Keep Who wins →
Axis Horizon vs Axis Atlas

Same 23 partners, half the payout — Horizon transfers at 1:1 where Atlas gets 1:2, so ₹2,000 of extra fee buys double the miles.

#28 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
Axis Horizon vs Axis Magnus (legacy)

₹3,000 of honest miles vs ₹12,500 of milestone firepower — Horizon wins under ₹1.75L a month, Magnus buries it above.

#28 Keep #6 Keep Who wins →
HSBC Premier (Metal) vs HSBC TravelOne

Same points, same ~20 partners, one bank — TravelOne wins under ₹2L a month; the ₹50L-relationship metal takes over above it.

#8 Keep #14 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Ashva vs IDFC FIRST Mayura

IDFC's metal siblings: same 5X/10X engine, but Mayura's ₹0.50 points and 0% forex out-net Ashva at every spend level we model — Ashva is the ₹2,999 consolation prize, not the smarter buy.

#13 Keep #11 Keep Who wins →
Emirates Skywards ICICI Bank Emeralde vs Emirates Skywards ICICI Bank Sapphiro

Same Emirates program, two doors: ₹10,000 of unlimited lounges and 2 miles/₹100 vs ₹5,000 of spend-gated lounges and 1.5 — the Emeralde earns its extra fee back in lounges alone.

#35 Keep #40 Downgrade Who wins →
Adani One ICICI Bank Signature vs MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank

Two ICICI travel co-brands, two closed loops: ₹5,000 of Adani airport points and 16 lounges vs ₹999 of MakeMyTrip myCash and 0.99% forex — one is an airport-app bet, the other the cheapest travel card ICICI makes.

#34 Downgrade #41 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Bank Rubyx vs ICICI Sapphiro

ICICI's ₹0.25 twins: Rubyx's railway lounges and ₹2,000 fee vs Sapphiro's movie perks and ₹3,500 — same weak points, and neither is a rewards card in 2026.

#53 Downgrade #52 Downgrade Who wins →
SBI Card MILES PRIME vs SBI Card MILES ELITE

Same 25-partner transfer hub, two price tags — at ₹1L a month PRIME's twin milestones net ₹27,000 to ELITE's ₹27,001, one rupee apart, for a point less on travel and half the lounges.

#30 Keep #37 Keep Who wins →
SBI Card MILES vs IRCTC SBI Card Premier

Two ₹1,499 SBI travel cards, opposite religions — MILES banks transferable Travel Credits into 25 airlines, IRCTC Premier banks 10% back that can only ever buy a train ticket.

#49 Downgrade #50 Keep Who wins →
Amex Platinum Reserve vs Amex Platinum Charge

₹10,000 of lounges-and-vouchers vs ₹66,000 of status-and-everything — Amex's two metal tiers, and the cheaper one keeps the points that neither card is really about.

#25 Keep #21 Keep Who wins →
Axis Miles & More World vs Axis Miles & More World Select

Same Lufthansa pipe, two throttle settings — 2% at ₹3,500 vs 3% at ₹4,500 with a ₹10,000 entry: the answer flips on how hard you spend.

#32 Keep #23 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Pinnacle World vs IndusInd Legend

Two IndusInd premium cards the 2025 nerfs hollowed out — Pinnacle keeps a lounge crumb and an online multiplier, Legend lost its lounges entirely.

#51 Keep #44 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Legend vs IndusInd Tiger

IndusInd's stripped-down Legend vs the lifetime-free Tiger — Tiger transfers to Maharaja at 1:1, Legend at a decoy 4:1, and only one costs ₹5,000 to walk in.

#44 Keep #12 Keep Who wins →
Axis Bank SELECT vs Axis Atlas

Two Axis travel cards, two different currencies: SELECT's twelve international lounges and portal-locked ₹0.20 EDGE points vs Atlas's 1:2 EDGE Miles that actually reach KrisFlyer.

#33 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
YES Bank RESERV vs YES Bank Marquee

Same bank, same YES Rewardz trap: RESERV's 3% at ₹2,499 vs Marquee's 4.5% at ₹9,999 — the fee quadruples for 1.5 points of online rate and a few more lounges.

#36 Downgrade #19 Keep Who wins →
Standard Chartered EaseMyTrip vs Standard Chartered Ultimate

Standard Chartered's cheapest and its best: a ₹350 EaseMyTrip coupon whose 10X skips EaseMyTrip, vs ₹5,000 of flat 3.33% at a fixed ₹1 a point.

#55 Downgrade #15 Keep Who wins →
Federal Bank Celesta vs Scapia (Federal Bank)

Federal Bank's two free travel cards: Celesta's 2 international lounges and 2% forex vs Scapia's 0% forex, unlimited domestic lounges and 2% coins — same bank, opposite bets.

#57 Keep #24 Keep Who wins →
IDFC FIRST Wealth vs IDFC FIRST Mayura

IDFC's free Visa Infinite vs its ₹5,999 metal flagship — 1.5% forex and never-expiring points against 0% forex and 13.3% portal multipliers.

#48 Keep #11 Keep Who wins →
AU Zenith+ vs AU Zenith

AU's confusing twins: ₹4,999 with 0.99% forex and golf vs ₹7,999 with more points and a concierge — the cheaper, better-named-worse card wins on paper.

#58 Cancel #45 Cancel Who wins →
AU Vetta vs AU Ananta

AU's two cheapest travel cards — Vetta's four Priority Pass visits at ₹2,999 vs Ananta's sixteen domestic lounges at ₹2,000, both paid in ₹0.25 points.

#54 Cancel #43 Cancel Who wins →
RBL Icon vs RBL World Safari

RBL's two travel cards — Icon's 20X weekend-and-abroad bands at 3.5% forex vs World Safari's plain 0% forex, which quietly out-earns it the moment you leave the country.

#38 Downgrade #39 Keep Who wins →
Tata Neu Infinity HDFC Bank vs HDFC Regalia Gold

HDFC's two sub-₹2,500 premiums: 5% inside the Tata universe that stays as ecosystem coins vs 5X on a curated brand list that becomes transferable points — lock-in against flexibility.

#27 Keep #10 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Diners Club Privilege vs HDFC Diners Club Black Metal

Same Diners badge, different engines: ₹1,000 of points that cap at ₹0.50 vs ₹10,000 of full ₹1 points, a 10,000-point quarterly bonus and airline transfers — you get what you pay for.

#20 Keep #5 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Diners Club Privilege vs HDFC Regalia Gold

Two trimmed HDFC mid-cards whose points never reach the house ₹1 — Diners' ₹0.50 SmartBuy redemptions and quarterly lounges vs Regalia Gold's ₹0.65 catalogue and milestone vouchers.

#20 Keep #10 Keep Who wins →

Across weight classes

Different segments, same wallet slot — the upgrade-or-not questions.

HDFC Infinia Metal vs Axis Atlas

India's most complete card against its most focused one — 3.3% on everything vs 4% that only pays out in miles.

#1 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
HDFC Diners Club Black Metal vs Axis Atlas

3.3% everything-points with SmartBuy caps vs 4% pure miles with a purged partner list.

#5 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Times Black vs Axis Magnus (legacy)

Experiences and a 1.49% forex vs milestones that pay ₹3.37L a year at ₹5L a month — two big fees, only one of them a rewards engine.

#18 Keep #6 Keep Who wins →
ICICI Times Black vs IDFC FIRST Mayura

₹20,000 of invite-only metal vs ₹5,999 of portal multipliers — Mayura nets ₹33,763 to Times Black's ₹4,000 at ₹1L a month.

#18 Keep #11 Keep Who wins →
YES Bank Marquee vs Standard Chartered Ultimate

Two flat engines with no transfer route worth using: 4.5% online that settles in portal travel vs 3.33% everywhere at a fixed ₹1 — the ceiling is the whole fight.

#19 Keep #15 Keep Who wins →
YES Bank Marquee vs Axis Atlas

4.5% back in ₹0.25 portal points vs 4% that becomes real miles — raw NAV says Marquee, every aspirational redemption says Atlas.

#19 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Avios Visa Infinite vs Axis Atlas

Avios that land straight in your BA or Qatar account vs EDGE Miles that double into KrisFlyer — direct simplicity against 1:2 transfer firepower.

#26 Keep #2 Keep Who wins →
IndusInd Avios Visa Infinite vs BOBCARD Etihad Guest Premium

Two airlines, two alliances, same ₹1/mile anchor — oneworld Avios at a ₹10,000 join vs Etihad Guest at ₹5,000 with milestone confetti.

#26 Keep #7 Keep Who wins →
Axis Miles & More World Select vs IndusInd Avios Visa Infinite

3% into Star Alliance vs 1.5% into oneworld — the harder-earning Lufthansa card against the direct-Avios co-brand with the bigger milestones.

#23 Keep #26 Keep Who wins →