Skip to content

Amex India claws back Membership Rewards points left on cancelled cards

On 9 November 2026 American Express India removed Membership Rewards points tied to cards cardholders had cancelled, some of them years ago, and some balances went negative. Two days later Amex backed down: its email to cardmembers restores every balance to where it stood on 8 November. Pooling still ends on 15 November.

Cards this affects

Update, 11 November 2026: Amex is putting the points back. In an email to affected cardmembers, reported by LiveFromALounge, American Express India says it has “decided to restore the Membership Rewards® points balance available on your Card Account as of 8 November 2026”, after “careful consideration of Card Members’ feedback”. Points earned or redeemed since then are accounted for, and the restored points land on one of your active Amex cards “within the next 48-72 hours”. Amex does not call the clawback a mistake. For cards cancelled from now on, its existing terms, including the 30-day rule below, still apply. The end of pooling goes ahead: the same email says balances show separately for each card from 16 November.

What to do now: check that your balance is back to its 8 November figure plus anything you have earned since. If it is not, write to Amex and quote the deduction lines. The original story follows.

On 9 November 2026, American Express India took Membership Rewards points out of cardholders’ accounts. The points were tied to cards the cardholders had cancelled, in some cases years earlier, while they kept other Amex cards open. Screenshots shared online and reported by Outlook Money and LiveFromALounge show deductions of 311,990, 75,715 and 53,528 points. One cardholder reported 2,388,090 points removed and a balance of minus 2,148,040.

Amex’s explanation, as both outlets report it: a technical issue let points from cancelled cards stay visible after the permitted period. Amex says it has fixed the issue and adjusted balances under its terms.

The terms do say that. Amex India’s own Membership Rewards terms (January 2026 edition) give a cancelled card’s points 30 days. Points not redeemed or transferred in that time “shall automatically get forfeited”. What the terms do not cover is the case that hurt here. While pooling was on, every card fed one balance, so nobody could see which points belonged to the card they closed. Amex then left those points on the balance, redeemable, for years.

What was unanswered on 9 November (the restore to 8 November balances settles the first):

  • How a negative balance would be settled. The terms reserve forfeiture and cancellation, but say nothing about a balance below zero.
  • How Amex worked out which redemptions came out of which card’s points. Cardholders on TechnoFino dispute exactly that.

Why the timing matters: this lands six days before Membership Rewards pooling ends on 15 November. From then on each card keeps its own balance, split from what you already hold.

Our take: the reversal fixes the balance, not the rule. Pooling ends on 15 November and every card then keeps its own balance, so treat each card’s points as tied to that card. Before you close any Amex card, transfer or redeem its points: after 30 days they are gone, and this time Amex will be within its terms.

Get the Monday email: every change on our tracker, the week it lands.

Mondays, skipped when nothing moved. Double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe. Privacy

Comparisons this changes

More on this story

  1. Amex India credit cards cap late fee at ₹1,250

  2. Amex Platinum Travel loses ₹1.9 lakh milestone, ₹7 lakh now gets ₹20,000 Taj voucher

  3. Amex Platinum Travel pushes its Taj voucher milestone to ₹7L

  4. Amex tightens MRCC's monthly bonus and devalues Gold Collection

  5. Amex Platinum Travel kills Flipkart redemption, devalues Taj by 20%

  6. Amex Platinum Charge goes metal, fee jumps to ₹60,000

Amex Membership Rewards

Sources

Published · All news · Every change since 1961 · Report an error