IDFC FIRST Private vs IDFC FIRST Mayura
IDFC FIRST Private by ₹6,300 a year at ₹75,000 a month
₹20,000 of metal vs ₹5,999 of portal multipliers — the lead swings back and forth with spend, and Times Black holds it at ₹3L a month; Mayura costs ₹14,001 less a year, so the metal has to win on its perks.
ICICI Times Black and IDFC FIRST Mayura trade places 6 times between ₹25,000 and ₹5 lakh a month (ICICI Times Black ahead at 15 of the 21 spends we test, IDFC FIRST Mayura at 6), so pick on the perks below rather than on earn alone. At ₹75,000 a month much of IDFC FIRST Mayura's edge is the fee: it costs ₹5,999 a year, while ICICI Times Black charges ₹20,000, even though ICICI Times Black pays bigger milestone bonuses. ICICI Times Black is the better pick if airport lounges matter more to you than the money: it gets you into 737 of the lounges we track to IDFC FIRST Mayura's 127.
| Fact | ICICI Times Black | IDFC FIRST Mayura |
|---|---|---|
| Can you get it | Open to apply | Open to apply |
| Fee (joining · annual, + GST) | ₹20,000/yr | ₹5,999/yr✓ Better |
| Fee waiver | Spend ₹25,00,000 a year | None |
| Reward rate on everyday spend | 2.0%✓ Better | 1.7% |
| Points | ICICI Reward Points | IDFC FIRST Reward Points |
| Our value per point | ₹1.00 | ₹0.25 † |
| Transfer partners | 2✓ Better | None |
| Lounges it gets you into | 737 of 810✓ Better | 127 of 810 |
| Forex markup | 1.49% + GST | Nil✓ Better |
| Welcome benefit | ₹12,000 Lohono / ₹10,000 EaseMyTrip stay voucher + ₹10,000 visa-services wallet (Atlys/OneVasco) + Toni&Guy ₹3,000 + Interflora ₹1,000 + Zomato Gold — application windows via timesblack.com | 12,000 RP — 4,000 on fee payment + 4,000 each on ₹20k in cycles 2 and 3 (once per customer) |
✓ Better marks the side that wins a row; rows that compare unlike things are not scored. IDFC FIRST Mayura is ahead on 8 of the 12 rows we can call.
| Fact | ICICI Times Black | IDFC FIRST Mayura |
|---|---|---|
| Our rank | #29 | #9✓ Better |
| Our verdict | Keep | Keep |
| Lounge visits in India | Unlimited at the 71 rooms on ICICI's consolidated domestic list, plus the 5 asterisked rooms reserved for Diamant, Emeralde Private Metal and Times Black | 4 visits/quarter (+4 railway lounge visits/quarter) at the 46 rooms on IDFC's own 48-row EliteAssist list that this map carries, NOT the Visa network |
| Lounge visits abroad | Unlimited (Priority Pass) | 4 visits/quarter |
| Forex, in the bank’s words | 1.49% + GST (card-specific carve-out in the MITC; standard ICICI rate is 3.5%) | Nil — 0% markup on foreign currency and DCC transactions |
| Interest (APR) | 3.75%/mo (45%/yr) | Dynamic 0.71%–3.85%/mo (8.5%–46.2%/yr); overdue rate 3.99%/mo (47.88%/yr) on MAD non-payment |
| Income needed (salaried) | ₹2,00,000+/month (official product page, seen 2026-08-01 — was community-reported only) | ~₹25L+/yr (community) |
| Income needed (self-employed) | ₹24,00,000+/yr (official product page) | ~₹25L+/yr (community) |
Where their lounge doors differ (ICICI Times Black against IDFC FIRST Mayura): New York (JFK) 10 against 0 · Tokyo (NRT) 9 against 0 · Dubai (DXB) 12 against 4.
† IDFC FIRST Mayura: Mayura is one of only two IDFC cards that reach ₹0.50 a point, and only on flight and hotel bookings made through the Travel & Shop section of the FIRST app — its own rewards T&C is explicit that it is "₹0.25 everywhere else", the house value. So the rate below is DOUBLE what these points fetch as vouchers, goods or pay-with-points; the earn rate marks them up to the ₹0.50 travel tier and assumes you actually book there. Points cover at most 70% of a booking, redemptions are capped at 150,000 points a month, and each one costs ₹99 + GST.
Our value per point is what we think a point is worth when you use it well; every currency's figure and its reasoning is on points values.
| Monthly spend | ICICI Times Black | IDFC FIRST Mayura |
|---|---|---|
| At ₹30,000 a month | −₹3,200 | ₹600✓ Better |
| At ₹75,000 a month | ₹16,900 | ₹19,700✓ Better |
| At ₹1.5 lakh a month | ₹43,800 | ₹48,900✓ Better |
| At ₹3 lakh a month | ₹1,17,700✓ Better | ₹99,900 |
| At ₹5 lakh a month | ₹1,62,800 | ₹1,67,900✓ Better |
| Pays for itself from | ₹42,000 a month | ₹29,000 a month✓ Better |
On an everyday mix of spending (groceries, bills, travel, fuel and the rest), using each card's own rules for each kind of spend. The same figures as each card's own page.
| Monthly spend | ICICI Times Black | IDFC FIRST Mayura | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹25,000 | −₹4,400 | −₹1,100✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹3,300 |
| ₹30,000 | −₹3,200 | ₹600✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹3,800 |
| ₹50,000 | ₹11,300✓ Better | ₹7,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹3,900 |
| ₹75,000 | ₹16,900 | ₹19,700✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹2,800 |
| ₹1 lakh | ₹32,600✓ Better | ₹28,200 | ICICI Times Black by ₹4,400 |
| ₹1.25 lakh | ₹38,200✓ Better | ₹36,700 | ICICI Times Black by ₹1,500 |
| ₹1.5 lakh | ₹43,800 | ₹48,900✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹5,100 |
| ₹1.75 lakh | ₹69,500✓ Better | ₹57,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹12,100 |
| ₹2 lakh | ₹75,100✓ Better | ₹65,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹9,200 |
| ₹2.25 lakh | ₹1,00,800✓ Better | ₹74,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹26,400 |
| ₹2.5 lakh | ₹1,06,400✓ Better | ₹82,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹23,500 |
| ₹2.75 lakh | ₹1,12,000✓ Better | ₹91,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹20,600 |
| ₹3 lakh | ₹1,17,700✓ Better | ₹99,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹17,800 |
| ₹3.25 lakh | ₹1,23,300✓ Better | ₹1,08,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹14,900 |
| ₹3.5 lakh | ₹1,29,000✓ Better | ₹1,16,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹12,100 |
| ₹3.75 lakh | ₹1,34,600✓ Better | ₹1,25,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹9,200 |
| ₹4 lakh | ₹1,40,200✓ Better | ₹1,33,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹6,300 |
| ₹4.25 lakh | ₹1,45,900✓ Better | ₹1,42,400 | ICICI Times Black by ₹3,500 |
| ₹4.5 lakh | ₹1,51,500✓ Better | ₹1,50,900 | ICICI Times Black by ₹600 |
| ₹4.75 lakh | ₹1,57,200 | ₹1,59,400✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹2,200 |
| ₹5 lakh | ₹1,62,800 | ₹1,67,900✓ Better | IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹5,100 |
We put each card through the same everyday mix of spending, apply that card's own rules for each kind of spend (some earn nothing on fuel or bills), add its milestone and renewal bonuses at our value per point, and take off the fee unless that spend waives it. Bonus categories that need you to shop a certain way are not counted. Your own mix will differ: try your numbers in the calculator, or read how we value cards.
ICICI Times Black's ICICI Reward Points move to 2 airline and hotel partners; IDFC FIRST Mayura's IDFC FIRST Reward Points cannot be moved to any.
Only ICICI Times Black: Air India Maharaja Club, iShop travel portal.
Every partner and ratio is on each card's page; the best value for your points is on the transfer optimizer.
ICICI Times Black and IDFC FIRST Mayura trade places 6 times between ₹25,000 and ₹5 lakh a month (ICICI Times Black ahead at 15 of the 21 spends we test, IDFC FIRST Mayura at 6), so pick on the perks below rather than on earn alone. At ₹75,000 a month much of IDFC FIRST Mayura's edge is the fee: it costs ₹5,999 a year, while ICICI Times Black charges ₹20,000, even though ICICI Times Black pays bigger milestone bonuses. ICICI Times Black is the better pick if airport lounges matter more to you than the money: it gets you into 737 of the lounges we track to IDFC FIRST Mayura's 127.
ICICI Times Black beats IDFC FIRST Mayura by ₹17,800 a year at ₹3 lakh a month. Both figures are a year's rewards and bonuses on an everyday spending mix, after the fee.
IDFC FIRST Mayura: ₹5,999/yr against ₹20,000/yr. ICICI Times Black waives its fee if you spend ₹25,00,000 a year; IDFC FIRST Mayura has no fee waiver.
ICICI Times Black: 737 of the 810 lounges we track, against 127 for IDFC FIRST Mayura. Visit limits and guest charges differ by card; each card's page lists them.
ICICI Times Black was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, IDFC FIRST Mayura on 14 Nov 2026. Every figure here is worked out again from those records each time the site is built, so a change to either card shows up the day we log it.
ICICI Times Black was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, IDFC FIRST Mayura on 14 Nov 2026. Every fact above comes from these 16 documents; the banks' own are marked official. A fact a bank does not publish shows as "not published", never as zero.