Skip to content

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature vs Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME

Verified 12 sources

Your monthly spend

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹4,000 a year at ₹30,000 a month: ₹7,200 against ₹3,200, after fees

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹17,600 a year at ₹75,000 a month: ₹28,000 against ₹10,400, after fees

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹30,300 a year at ₹1.5 lakh a month: ₹46,000 against ₹15,700, after fees

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹55,700 a year at ₹3 lakh a month: ₹82,000 against ₹26,300, after fees

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹89,600 a year at ₹5 lakh a month: ₹1,30,000 against ₹40,400, after fees

ICICI Bank

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature

Our verdict: Keep Closed

SBI Card

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME

Our verdict: Keep Closed

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME vs MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature: which should you pick?

At every spend from ₹25,000 to ₹5 lakh a month, Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature, and its lead widens from ₹3,100 to ₹89,600 a year as spend climbs. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME returns ₹18,000 a year in rewards to MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature's ₹5,300. On the rows below, MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature has no clear edge over Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME. Neither Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME nor MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature runs a 2.0% booster on MakeMyTrip hotel & holiday bookings, where Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME earns one flat rate; MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature charges ₹2,500 once at issuance and nothing to renew.

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature review Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME review

Side by side

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature and Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME, fact by fact
FactMakeMyTrip ICICI Bank SignatureClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME
Can you get itClosed to new applicantsClosed to new applicants
Fee (joining · annual, + GST)₹0/yr · ₹2,500 joining (one-time)✓ Better₹0/yr · ₹2,999 joining (one-time)
Fee waiverNoneNone
Reward rate on everyday spend0.6%2.0%✓ Better
PointsMakeMyTrip myCashAir India Maharaja Points
Our value per point₹1.00₹1.00 †
Transfer partnersNoneNone
Lounges it gets you into757 of 810✓ Better688 of 810
Forex markup3.5% + GST3.5% + GST
Welcome benefitMMTBLACK Platinum tier + a MakeMyTrip holiday voucher up to ₹2,500 — one-time, on joining. CLOSED TO NEW APPLICATIONS.not published

✓ Better marks the side that wins a row; rows that compare unlike things are not scored. Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME is ahead on 6 of the 8 rows we can call.

More facts 6 rows
Rank, verdict, lounge visits and fine print
FactMakeMyTrip ICICI Bank SignatureClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME
Our rankNot ranked (closed)Not ranked (closed)
Our verdictKeepKeep
Lounge visits in India8/year (2/quarter) at the 71 rooms on ICICI's consolidated domestic list + 1 railway lounge visit/quarter8 visits/year (max 2/quarter) at SBI's 30-room Set B list only
Lounge visits abroad1/year (Priority Pass for cards applied for on/after 15-Nov-2024; DreamFolks for earlier holders)4 Priority Pass visits/year OUTSIDE India (max 2/quarter, primary cardholder only); membership complimentary for 24 months
Forex, in the bank’s words3.5% + GST3.5% + GST — SBI's markup table names ELITE and AURUM as the only 1.99% exceptions, so this card sits at the standard rate; dynamic and static DCC also 3.5%
Interest (APR)3.75%/mo (45%/yr)not published

Where their lounge doors differ (MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature against Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME): Asansol (ASN) 3 against 0 · Mumbai (BOM) 5 against 3 · Chennai (MAA) 4 against 2.

† Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME: Priced at the ₹1.00 Air India Maharaja house value, because that is the programme the points now live in. SBI's card copy has never been updated from "CV Points", so a holder reading the product page and a holder reading their Maharaja Club balance are looking at the same points under two names.

Neither issuer publishes an income floor for these two, and the door is the same on both sides: MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature and Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME are both closed to new applications, and only grandfathered holders still have it. How people actually get each one is on its card page.

Our value per point is what we think a point is worth when you use it well; every currency's figure and its reasoning is on points values.

What each is worth to you

A year of rewards and bonuses, after the fee
Monthly spendMakeMyTrip ICICI Bank SignatureClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME
At ₹30,000 a month₹3,200₹7,200✓ Better
At ₹75,000 a month₹10,400₹28,000✓ Better
At ₹1.5 lakh a month₹15,700₹46,000✓ Better
At ₹3 lakh a month₹26,300₹82,000✓ Better
At ₹5 lakh a month₹40,400₹1,30,000✓ Better
Pays for itself fromThe first rupeeThe first rupee

On an everyday mix of spending (groceries, bills, travel, fuel and the rest), using each card's own rules for each kind of spend. The same figures as each card's own page.

Every spend from ₹25,000 to ₹5 lakh 21 steps
MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature and Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME at each spend we test
Monthly spendMakeMyTrip ICICI Bank SignatureClub Vistara SBI Card PRIMEAhead
₹25,000₹2,900₹6,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹3,100
₹30,000₹3,200₹7,200✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹4,000
₹50,000₹8,600₹12,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹3,400
₹75,000₹10,400₹28,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹17,600
₹1 lakh₹12,200₹34,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹21,800
₹1.25 lakh₹13,900₹40,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹26,100
₹1.5 lakh₹15,700₹46,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹30,300
₹1.75 lakh₹17,400₹52,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹34,600
₹2 lakh₹19,200₹58,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹38,800
₹2.25 lakh₹21,000₹64,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹43,000
₹2.5 lakh₹22,700₹70,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹47,300
₹2.75 lakh₹24,500₹76,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹51,500
₹3 lakh₹26,300₹82,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹55,700
₹3.25 lakh₹28,000₹88,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹60,000
₹3.5 lakh₹29,800₹94,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹64,200
₹3.75 lakh₹31,500₹1,00,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹68,500
₹4 lakh₹33,300₹1,06,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹72,700
₹4.25 lakh₹35,100₹1,12,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹76,900
₹4.5 lakh₹36,800₹1,18,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹81,200
₹4.75 lakh₹38,600₹1,24,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹85,400
₹5 lakh₹40,400₹1,30,000✓ BetterClub Vistara SBI Card PRIME by ₹89,600
How we work out the yearly value

We put each card through the same everyday mix of spending, apply that card's own rules for each kind of spend (some earn nothing on fuel or bills), add its milestone and renewal bonuses at our value per point, and take off the fee unless that spend waives it. Bonus categories that need you to shop a certain way are not counted. Your own mix will differ: try your numbers in the calculator, or read how we value cards.

Before you choose

Transfer partners 0 and 0

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature's MakeMyTrip myCash cannot be moved to any airline or hotel; Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME's Air India Maharaja Points cannot be moved to any.

Every partner and ratio is on each card's page; the best value for your points is on the transfer optimizer.

Watch out 6 points

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature

  • Closed to new applications — ICICI's own page says so
  • Everything earns per ₹200, not ₹100: base spends are 0.625%, MMT flights just 1%
  • Milestone myCash needs ₹2.5L and ₹5L of spend on a card you shouldn't be spending on

4 more on its page

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME

  • Closed to new applications — SBI's own product record sets this card unavailable online and the page carries no Apply Now button; existing holders keep it
  • The four Premium Economy ticket vouchers are discontinued for every card renewing after 31 March 2025 — that is almost certainly you
  • Your CV Points are Air India Maharaja Points now: Club Vistara folded into Maharaja Club on 12 November 2024 and SBI's card copy was never rewritten

4 more on its page

Common questions 5 answered

Which is better, MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature or Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME?

At every spend from ₹25,000 to ₹5 lakh a month, Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature, and its lead widens from ₹3,100 to ₹89,600 a year as spend climbs. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME returns ₹18,000 a year in rewards to MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature's ₹5,300. On the rows below, MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature has no clear edge over Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME. Neither Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME nor MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature or Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME: which is worth more at ₹3 lakh a month?

Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME beats MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature by ₹55,700 a year at ₹3 lakh a month. Both figures are a year's rewards and bonuses on an everyday spending mix, after the fee.

Which costs less to get, MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature or Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME?

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature: ₹0/yr · ₹2,500 joining (one-time) against ₹0/yr · ₹2,999 joining (one-time). MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature has no fee waiver; Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME has no fee waiver.

Which gets you into more airport lounges, MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature or Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME?

MakeMyTrip ICICI Bank Signature: 757 of the 810 lounges we track, against 688 for Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME. Visit limits and guest charges differ by card; each card's page lists them.

How current is this comparison?

Both cards were last checked against their banks' own documents on 17 Nov 2026. Every figure here is worked out again from those records each time the site is built, so a change to either card shows up the day we log it.

Get the Monday email: every fee and devaluation that moved on these cards and the rest, in ₹.

Mondays, skipped when nothing moved. Double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe. Privacy

Sources

Both cards were last checked against their banks' own documents on 17 Nov 2026. Every fact above comes from these 12 documents; the banks' own are marked official. A fact a bank does not publish shows as "not published", never as zero.

The documents 12 sources
  1. Official ICICI change notice (6 Nov 2026 edition) — complimentary INOX movie benefit discontinued from 15 Dec 2026 read
  2. Official Product page — ₹2,500 joining / nil annual, 8 domestic (₹75k quarterly gate) + 1 international + quarterly railway lounges, 3.5% forex, MMTBLACK Platinum read
  3. Official Membership guide — the rate table headed "My Cash (per ₹200 spent)": domestic outside MMT ₹1.25, international outside MMT ₹1.5, MMT flights ₹2, MMT hotel/holiday ₹4 read
  4. Official MITC ("Last updated on Aug 2nd, 2026") — ₹2,500 joining, NIL annual fee, no spend threshold, ₹199 add-on; APR 3.75%/mo (45%/yr) read
  5. Official The live ₹999 MakeMyTrip ICICI card — the replacement product, earning per ₹100 read
  6. Official SBI Card product page — ₹2,999 + taxes annual fee, renewal nil, 4 points per ₹200 on all retail including fuel, 8 domestic lounge visits, 4 Priority Pass visits outside India read
  7. Official SBI's own product record behind that page — the card is flagged as not available online, which is the issuer's own evidence that it is withdrawn from sale read
  8. Official Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME terms booklet — the renewal Premium Economy voucher is discontinued where the renewal fee falls after 31 March 2025, and the ₹2,999 is waived read
  9. Official Air India Maharaja Club partner directory — the SBI–Air India co-brand is the only co-brand listed; no Club Vistara SBI entry exists read
  10. Community SBI Card's domestic lounge rules from 10 January 2026 — tiered lounge lists plus a ₹2 authorization charge and a ₹25 validation hold on every visit read
  11. Official SBI Airport Lounge Access — "Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME" is named in SET B, the 30-room roster w.e.f. 10 Jan 2026 read
  12. Official SBI's MITC fee table still prints "Club Vistara SBI Card PRIME / 2,999 / 2,999" — the generic row the card-specific booklet overrides, which is why this card renews at nothing read

Report a wrong fact on this page