Amex Membership Rewards Card vs HDFC Regalia Gold
HDFC Regalia Gold by ₹10,200 a year at ₹75,000 a month
American Express
Amex's two cheap doors into the same Membership Rewards pool — ₹495 with three hard monthly caps against ₹4,500 with two easy monthly milestones. Identical transfer partners, opposite kinds of discipline.
Both earn Amex Membership Rewards, so Amex SmartEarn and Amex Membership Rewards Card share every transfer partner and differ only in how fast they earn and what they cost. Whatever you spend between ₹25,000 and ₹5 lakh a month, Amex Membership Rewards Card comes out roughly ₹10,500 a year ahead of Amex SmartEarn. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: Amex Membership Rewards Card returns ₹19,600 a year in rewards to Amex SmartEarn's ₹7,600. Amex SmartEarn is the better pick if you would rather pay less to get the card: Amex SmartEarn costs ₹495/yr, Amex Membership Rewards Card ₹1,000 joining, then ₹4,500/yr. Neither Amex Membership Rewards Card nor Amex SmartEarn takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.
Amex SmartEarn pays 3 annual spend milestones, the first at ₹1,20,000 a year, and Amex Membership Rewards Card pays none; Amex SmartEarn runs a 8.3% booster on 10X/5X partner merchants (capped), where Amex Membership Rewards Card earns one flat rate.
| Fact | Amex SmartEarn | Amex Membership Rewards Card |
|---|---|---|
| Can you get it | Paused, not issuing | Paused, not issuing |
| Fee (joining · annual, + GST) | ₹495/yr✓ Better | ₹1,000 joining, then ₹4,500/yr |
| Fee waiver | Spend ₹40,000 a year | Spend ₹1,50,000 a year |
| Reward rate on everyday spend | 1.0% | 1.0% |
| Points | Amex Membership Rewards | Amex Membership Rewards |
| Our value per point | ₹0.50 | ₹0.50 |
| Transfer partners | 8 | 8 |
| Lounges it gets you into | 0 of 810 | 0 of 810 |
| Forex markup | 3.5% | 3.5% + GST |
| Welcome benefit | ₹500 statement credit on ₹10,000 spend in the first 90 days | 4,000 MR on ₹15,000 of spend in 90 days |
✓ Better marks the side that wins a row; rows that compare unlike things are not scored. Amex Membership Rewards Card is ahead on 5 of the 7 rows we can call.
| Fact | Amex SmartEarn | Amex Membership Rewards Card |
|---|---|---|
| Our rank | Not ranked (paused) | Not ranked (paused) |
| Our verdict | Keep | Keep |
| Lounge visits in India | not published | None |
| Lounge visits abroad | not published | None |
| Forex, in the bank’s words | 3.5% (currency conversion factor assessment) + GST | 3.5% + GST |
| Interest (APR) | 3.5%/mo (42%/yr) | 3.5%/mo (42%/yr); 3.99%/mo (47.88%/yr) in cases of default |
| Income needed (salaried) | not published | ₹6L+/yr (community) |
| Income needed (self-employed) | not published | ₹6L+/yr (community) |
Our value per point is what we think a point is worth when you use it well; every currency's figure and its reasoning is on points values.
| Monthly spend | Amex SmartEarn | Amex Membership Rewards Card |
|---|---|---|
| At ₹30,000 a month | ₹4,500 | ₹15,000✓ Better |
| At ₹75,000 a month | ₹9,100 | ₹19,600✓ Better |
| At ₹1.5 lakh a month | ₹16,600 | ₹27,100✓ Better |
| At ₹3 lakh a month | ₹31,700 | ₹42,200✓ Better |
| At ₹5 lakh a month | ₹51,900 | ₹62,400✓ Better |
| Pays for itself from | ₹4,000 a month, by waiving its fee✓ Better | ₹15,000 a month, by waiving its fee |
On an everyday mix of spending (groceries, bills, travel, fuel and the rest), using each card's own rules for each kind of spend. The same figures as each card's own page.
| Monthly spend | Amex SmartEarn | Amex Membership Rewards Card | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹25,000 | ₹4,000 | ₹14,500✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹30,000 | ₹4,500 | ₹15,000✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹50,000 | ₹6,500 | ₹17,000✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹75,000 | ₹9,100 | ₹19,600✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹1 lakh | ₹11,600 | ₹22,100✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹1.25 lakh | ₹14,100 | ₹24,600✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹1.5 lakh | ₹16,600 | ₹27,100✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹1.75 lakh | ₹19,100 | ₹29,600✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹2 lakh | ₹21,700 | ₹32,200✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹2.25 lakh | ₹24,200 | ₹34,700✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹2.5 lakh | ₹26,700 | ₹37,200✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹2.75 lakh | ₹29,200 | ₹39,700✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹3 lakh | ₹31,700 | ₹42,200✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹3.25 lakh | ₹34,300 | ₹44,800✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹3.5 lakh | ₹36,800 | ₹47,300✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹3.75 lakh | ₹39,300 | ₹49,800✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹4 lakh | ₹41,800 | ₹52,300✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹4.25 lakh | ₹44,300 | ₹54,800✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹4.5 lakh | ₹46,900 | ₹57,400✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹4.75 lakh | ₹49,400 | ₹59,900✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
| ₹5 lakh | ₹51,900 | ₹62,400✓ Better | Amex Membership Rewards Card by ₹10,500 |
We put each card through the same everyday mix of spending, apply that card's own rules for each kind of spend (some earn nothing on fuel or bills), add its milestone and renewal bonuses at our value per point, and take off the fee unless that spend waives it. Bonus categories that need you to shop a certain way are not counted. Your own mix will differ: try your numbers in the calculator, or read how we value cards.
Both cards earn Amex Membership Rewards, so they move points to the same 8 partners .
| Partner | Amex SmartEarn | Amex Membership Rewards Card |
|---|---|---|
| Singapore Airlines KrisFlyer | 2:1 | 2:1 |
| Qatar Airways Privilege Club (Avios) | 2:1 | 2:1 |
| The British Airways Club (Avios) | 2:1 | 2:1 |
Every partner and ratio is on each card's page; the best value for your points is on the transfer optimizer.
Both earn Amex Membership Rewards, so Amex SmartEarn and Amex Membership Rewards Card share every transfer partner and differ only in how fast they earn and what they cost. Whatever you spend between ₹25,000 and ₹5 lakh a month, Amex Membership Rewards Card comes out roughly ₹10,500 a year ahead of Amex SmartEarn. At ₹75,000 a month the gap is mostly what each card earns on your spend: Amex Membership Rewards Card returns ₹19,600 a year in rewards to Amex SmartEarn's ₹7,600. Amex SmartEarn is the better pick if you would rather pay less to get the card: Amex SmartEarn costs ₹495/yr, Amex Membership Rewards Card ₹1,000 joining, then ₹4,500/yr. Neither Amex Membership Rewards Card nor Amex SmartEarn takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.
Amex Membership Rewards Card beats Amex SmartEarn by ₹10,500 a year at ₹3 lakh a month. Both figures are a year's rewards and bonuses on an everyday spending mix, after the fee.
Amex SmartEarn: ₹495/yr against ₹1,000 joining, then ₹4,500/yr. Amex SmartEarn waives its fee if you spend ₹40,000 a year; Amex Membership Rewards Card waives its fee if you spend ₹1,50,000 a year.
Both get you into 0 of the 810 lounges we track.
Amex SmartEarn was last checked against its bank's own documents on 19 Nov 2026, Amex Membership Rewards Card on 17 Nov 2026. Every figure here is worked out again from those records each time the site is built, so a change to either card shows up the day we log it.
Amex SmartEarn was last checked against its bank's own documents on 19 Nov 2026, Amex Membership Rewards Card on 17 Nov 2026. Every fact above comes from these 14 documents; the banks' own are marked official. A fact a bank does not publish shows as "not published", never as zero.