Skip to content

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card vs ICICI Bank HPCL Silver

Verified 8 sources

Your monthly spend

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹3,900 a year at ₹30,000 a month: ₹4,300 against ₹400, after fees

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹5,200 a year at ₹75,000 a month: ₹7,000 against ₹1,800, after fees

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹7,500 a year at ₹1.5 lakh a month: ₹11,500 against ₹4,000, after fees

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹12,000 a year at ₹3 lakh a month: ₹20,500 against ₹8,500, after fees

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹18,000 a year at ₹5 lakh a month: ₹32,500 against ₹14,500, after fees

IndusInd Bank

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card

Our verdict: Cancel Closed

ICICI Bank

ICICI Bank HPCL Silver

Our verdict: Cancel Closed

ICICI Bank HPCL Silver vs IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card: which should you pick?

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver both earn PAYBACK Points (now Zillion Coins), so the transfer partners are the same; what separates them is how fast each earns and what each costs. IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card is the better card at every spend we test, and its lead over ICICI Bank HPCL Silver grows as you spend more: ₹3,700 a year at ₹25,000 a month, ₹18,000 at ₹5 lakh. At ₹75,000 a month most of IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card's edge is its milestone and renewal bonuses, worth ₹2,500 a year, where ICICI Bank HPCL Silver pays none at that spend. We found nothing ICICI Bank HPCL Silver does clearly better than IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card on the rows below. Neither IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card nor ICICI Bank HPCL Silver takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card pays 2 annual spend milestones, the first at ₹2,00,000 a year, and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver pays none; IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card runs a 5.0% booster on Movie bookings, where ICICI Bank HPCL Silver earns one flat rate.

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card review ICICI Bank HPCL Silver review

Side by side

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver, fact by fact
FactIndusInd PAYBACK Credit CardICICI Bank HPCL Silver
Can you get itClosed to new applicantsClosed to new applicants
Fee (joining · annual, + GST)₹0/yr · ₹249 joining (one-time)✓ Better₹500/yr
Fee waiverNoneNone
Reward rate on everyday spend0.5%✓ Better0.3%
PointsPAYBACK Points (now Zillion Coins)PAYBACK Points (now Zillion Coins)
Our value per point₹0.25₹0.25 †
Transfer partnersNoneNone
Lounges it gets you into0 of 8100 of 810
Forex markupnot publishednot published
Welcome benefitnot publishednot published

✓ Better marks the side that wins a row; rows that compare unlike things are not scored. IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card is ahead on 8 of the 8 rows we can call.

More facts 5 rows
Rank, verdict, lounge visits and fine print
FactIndusInd PAYBACK Credit CardICICI Bank HPCL Silver
Our rankNot ranked (closed)Not ranked (closed)
Our verdictCancelCancel
Lounge visits in Indianot publishednot published
Lounge visits abroadnot publishednot published
Interest (APR)not publishednot published

† ICICI Bank HPCL Silver: i-mint points at the house ₹0.25 — one unit under three names, i-mint to PAYBACK on 1 July 2011 to Zillion in May 2023, all three run by Loyalty Solutions & Research, which renamed the balance rather than converting it. One i-mint point per ₹100 is 0.25%. HPCL fuel is NOT in that figure — see the earn comment.

Neither issuer publishes an income floor for these two, and the door is the same on both sides: IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver are both closed to new applications, and only grandfathered holders still have it. How people actually get each one is on its card page.

Our value per point is what we think a point is worth when you use it well; every currency's figure and its reasoning is on points values.

What each is worth to you

A year of rewards and bonuses, after the fee
Monthly spendIndusInd PAYBACK Credit CardICICI Bank HPCL Silver
At ₹30,000 a month₹4,300✓ Better₹400
At ₹75,000 a month₹7,000✓ Better₹1,800
At ₹1.5 lakh a month₹11,500✓ Better₹4,000
At ₹3 lakh a month₹20,500✓ Better₹8,500
At ₹5 lakh a month₹32,500✓ Better₹14,500
Pays for itself fromThe first rupee✓ Better₹17,000 a month

On an everyday mix of spending (groceries, bills, travel, fuel and the rest), using each card's own rules for each kind of spend. The same figures as each card's own page.

Every spend from ₹25,000 to ₹5 lakh 21 steps
IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver at each spend we test
Monthly spendIndusInd PAYBACK Credit CardICICI Bank HPCL SilverAhead
₹25,000₹4,000✓ Better₹300IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹3,700
₹30,000₹4,300✓ Better₹400IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹3,900
₹50,000₹5,500✓ Better₹1,000IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹4,500
₹75,000₹7,000✓ Better₹1,800IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹5,200
₹1 lakh₹8,500✓ Better₹2,500IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹6,000
₹1.25 lakh₹10,000✓ Better₹3,300IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹6,700
₹1.5 lakh₹11,500✓ Better₹4,000IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹7,500
₹1.75 lakh₹13,000✓ Better₹4,800IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹8,200
₹2 lakh₹14,500✓ Better₹5,500IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹9,000
₹2.25 lakh₹16,000✓ Better₹6,300IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹9,700
₹2.5 lakh₹17,500✓ Better₹7,000IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹10,500
₹2.75 lakh₹19,000✓ Better₹7,800IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹11,200
₹3 lakh₹20,500✓ Better₹8,500IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹12,000
₹3.25 lakh₹22,000✓ Better₹9,300IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹12,700
₹3.5 lakh₹23,500✓ Better₹10,000IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹13,500
₹3.75 lakh₹25,000✓ Better₹10,800IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹14,200
₹4 lakh₹26,500✓ Better₹11,500IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹15,000
₹4.25 lakh₹28,000✓ Better₹12,300IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹15,700
₹4.5 lakh₹29,500✓ Better₹13,000IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹16,500
₹4.75 lakh₹31,000✓ Better₹13,800IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹17,200
₹5 lakh₹32,500✓ Better₹14,500IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card by ₹18,000
How we work out the yearly value

We put each card through the same everyday mix of spending, apply that card's own rules for each kind of spend (some earn nothing on fuel or bills), add its milestone and renewal bonuses at our value per point, and take off the fee unless that spend waives it. Bonus categories that need you to shop a certain way are not counted. Your own mix will differ: try your numbers in the calculator, or read how we value cards.

Before you choose

Transfer partners 0 shared

Both cards earn PAYBACK Points (now Zillion Coins), so they move points to the same 0 partners .

Every partner and ratio is on each card's page; the best value for your points is on the transfer optimizer.

Watch out 6 points

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card

  • Discontinued — IndusInd's own page is headed "Payback Credit Card (Discontinued)" and shows it only as a reference for existing cardholders
  • PAYBACK is a coalition programme run by another company, not an IndusInd scheme — the points reach no airline and no hotel
  • PAYBACK is now Zillion, and payback.in is a dead domain — a balance from this card lives at zillionrewards.in or nowhere

5 more on its page

ICICI Bank HPCL Silver

  • CLOSED — ICICI publishes no product page for this tier and its live credit-card listing routes only to HPCL Coral and HPCL Super Saver
  • The fee is the higher one in the family: ICICI's August 2026 MITC says a joining and annual fee of ₹500 "shall continue as communicated at the time of sourcing" for the Coral, Silver, Titanium, Gold and Platinum variants, while the surviving three carry a ₹199 line of their own
  • No spend-based fee reversal is published for this tier — the ₹50,000 bar in ICICI's fee table belongs to the Platinum, Titanium and Coral row

4 more on its page

Common questions 5 answered

Which is better, IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card or ICICI Bank HPCL Silver?

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card and ICICI Bank HPCL Silver both earn PAYBACK Points (now Zillion Coins), so the transfer partners are the same; what separates them is how fast each earns and what each costs. IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card is the better card at every spend we test, and its lead over ICICI Bank HPCL Silver grows as you spend more: ₹3,700 a year at ₹25,000 a month, ₹18,000 at ₹5 lakh. At ₹75,000 a month most of IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card's edge is its milestone and renewal bonuses, worth ₹2,500 a year, where ICICI Bank HPCL Silver pays none at that spend. We found nothing ICICI Bank HPCL Silver does clearly better than IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card on the rows below. Neither IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card nor ICICI Bank HPCL Silver takes new applications today, so this comparison is for people who already have one of them.

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card or ICICI Bank HPCL Silver: which is worth more at ₹3 lakh a month?

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card beats ICICI Bank HPCL Silver by ₹12,000 a year at ₹3 lakh a month. Both figures are a year's rewards and bonuses on an everyday spending mix, after the fee.

Which costs less to get, IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card or ICICI Bank HPCL Silver?

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card: ₹0/yr · ₹249 joining (one-time) against ₹500/yr. IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card has no fee waiver; ICICI Bank HPCL Silver has no fee waiver.

Which gets you into more airport lounges, IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card or ICICI Bank HPCL Silver?

Both get you into 0 of the 810 lounges we track.

How current is this comparison?

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, ICICI Bank HPCL Silver on 23 Aug 2026. Every figure here is worked out again from those records each time the site is built, so a change to either card shows up the day we log it.

Get the Monday email: every fee and devaluation that moved on these cards and the rest, in ₹.

Mondays, skipped when nothing moved. Double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe. Privacy

Sources

IndusInd PAYBACK Credit Card was last checked against its bank's own documents on 17 Nov 2026, ICICI Bank HPCL Silver on 23 Aug 2026. Every fact above comes from these 8 documents; the banks' own are marked official. A fact a bank does not publish shows as "not published", never as zero.

The documents 8 sources
  1. Official IndusInd PAYBACK product page, archived 22 July 2024 — the discontinuation notice, the ₹249 one-time joining fee, the PAYBACK partnership and the coalition-stacking mechanic read
  2. Official Zillion programme terms — PAYBACK India under its current name and operator, with the three-year coin expiry and the ban on transferring coins to anyone else read
  3. Official ICICI Bank's own co-branded credit-card index (archived 03-Jan-2012) — the page that lists "ICICI Bank HPCL Silver" as a card in its own right, with its exclusive features read
  4. Official ICICI's current credit-card MITC — the only live document that still names the HPCL Silver variant, and the ₹500 joining-and-annual figure it attaches to it read
  5. Official ICICI's live credit-card listing — every HPCL link on it goes to HPCL Coral or HPCL Super Saver, and no Silver page exists read
  6. Official ICICI Bank's press release of 19 November 2004 (archived 25-Nov-2010) — the September 2001 launch, the million-card milestone and the product features in the bank's own words read
  7. Official The loyalty programme's own FAQ, published on payback.in during the changeover (archived 01-Jul-2011) — it names i-mint and PAYBACK in one document and says the points were renamed, not converted read
  8. Official HPCL's own page for the programme, archived 24-Oct-2013 — the partner's confirmation that the co-brand ran in Gold and Silver tiers on both card schemes read

Report a wrong fact on this page